Lemon Gooey Butter Cookies

A house favorite, our Gooey Butter Cookies are in a league of their own. These lemon gooey butter cookies, cakey, gooey and are made fresh daily and guaranteed to melt-in-your-mouth. Order extra to savor the goodness. They are THAT GOOD. You will receive 12 gooeys. Each cookie is heat sealed individually and shipped in our signature pink and white striped box.

Warm Weather Shipping Notice

During warmer months, we strongly recommend Overnight Shipping for our Gooey Cookies to help ensure they arrive in the best possible condition.

Because our Gooeys are soft, rich, and moisture-filled, warm temperatures and longer transit times can affect their texture and may cause excess moisture inside the packaging.

Customers who do not choose Overnight Shipping during warm weather do so at their own discretion. Whimsy Cookie Co. cannot be responsible for heat- or moisture-related changes that may occur during transit when Overnight Shipping is not selected.

For the best Gooey experience, we recommend choosing Overnight Shipping during warm-weather months.