Call Us! 3

Jolly Butter Mix

Santa Will Put You On The Extra Good List

Jolly Butter Mix

$44.50 for 12 cookies

Special deal that simply cannot be beat!!  Enjoy our famous sugar cookies and our ever popular assorted mix of gooey butters cookies..the perfect gift to give or to enjoy for yourself!!  Each cookie is heat sealed in cello bags and shipped in our signature pink and white striped box.

  • 2 Santa belts
  • 2 Elf cookies
  • 2 Gingie faces
  • 1 Birthday Cake Gooey Butter cookie
  • 1 Strawberry Gooey Butter cookie
  • 1 Original Gooey Butter cookie
  • 1 Chocolate Gooey Butter cookie
  • 1 Lemon Gooey Butter cookie
  • 1 Red Velvet Gooey Butter cookie

Please Note! There is a strawberry shortage! We will substitute butter gooey in its place if strawberry is not available





Please be sure to read our Pick Up/Shipping Notice below before you check out!

Out of stock

Delivery & Shipping Notice

Whimsy HQ Shipping & Delivery

While we are in transition in our new kitchen space, Whimsy HQ is offering delivery only. Because our cookies are made to order, we will need at least 3 business days notice for deliveries. If you need your cookies shipped, please know that it takes 3 - 4 business days to make, decorate, and package your cookies before they can be shipped and during non holidays. Don't forget we begin baking your cookies once an order is received to ensure that you receive the best Whimsy Cookies as possible!! If you need cookies earlier, please don't hesitate to ask, we will do our best to fit your order in, if at all possible! Leave us a message in our notes section at checkout.

Pick Up in all other locations

Because our Whimsy locations make your cookies to order, we will need at least a 3 business day notice on all pick up orders. If you do need an order earlier, it doesn't hurt to ask, we may not be able to accommodate your order, but we will be glad to check our calendar and do the best we can!! Leave us your desired pick up date in the notes section at checkout.

Allergen Notice

All of our cookies are made in a kitchen that handles dairy, egg, tree nuts, wheat, peanuts, soy. Please note that we cannot guarantee that any of our menu items are free of allergens because we share equipment and handle common allergens throughout our bakeries. Ultimately, it is the responsibility of the consumer to check all ingredients.

We are not a gluten free bakery and cannot guarantee cross contamination will never occur. However, we have a process in place to minimize this from happening. All of our products are made with the same equipment. Customers with gluten sensitivities should exercise judgement in consuming these cookies.